Can I customize my pizza toppings?

Yes, with our Build your own pizza option, you can select your own toppings to your liking. You can also choose to have a different set of toppings on the left and different on the right for your pizza.

What temperature should I bake my pizza at?

Preheat your oven to 375°F and bake your pizza on the center rack. Depending on your oven, it typically takes 20–30 minutes. You'll know it's done when the cheese is melted and bubbly with golden edges.

Do you take orders over the phone?

Yes! Feel free to call ahead with your order, or you can place an order online for pickup.

What sizes pizza do you offer?

We offer multiple sizes to fit any appetite or occasion. Our pizza sizes typically vary from 10", 12", 14" and 16".

Do you offer kids pizza as well?

Yes, we do. You can also add toppings of your choice to the pizza as you need to create a pizza that they love.

Eaton’s Fresh Pizza Sheboygan | Best Take & Bake Pizza Near You

Loading hours...

Order Online

Working Hours

Monday

Tuesday

Wednesday

Thursday

Friday

Saturday

Sunday

11 :00 am – 7:00  pm

11:00 am – 7:00  pm

Order Online

Get Direction

Satisfied
Customers

Clayton A. Google

Eaton's is the best take n bake pizza in town. They have a ton of different specialty pizzas, I find it difficult to pick which one sometimes!

Rob S. Google

Hands down the best pizza around. Eaton's has a hard working crew putting out a delicious and consistent product with no skimping on toppings.

Chris C. Google

Great pizza,great cookies and at a decent price. Stop there for your next pizza and you won’t be disappointed. This is pick up and bake at home pizza store.

William A. Google

The best fresh take 'n bake pizza I ever had. Pizza was absolutely delicious!! Service was friendly and efficient. I will definitely be a repeat customer.

Kathryn E. Google

Eaton's pizza never disappoints! It is great to have a place I trust to make gluten free pizza, with dedicated gluten free ingredients and pizza build station.

Take and Bake

Fresh Pizza, Done Right on
N 15th Street

At Eaton's Fresh Pizza in Sheboygan, every pizza is handcrafted daily with generous toppings and fresh ingredients, all so you can pull it out of your own oven and enjoy a meal that truly tastes homemade.

Tucked right on N 15th Street, we've quickly become a neighborhood favorite for Sheboygan families who want something better than ordinary takeout. With Eaton's, you get the quality of a scratch-made pizza with the ease and comfort of baking it yourself at home.

Our Sheboygan team puts care into every order, from the first topping to the last slice, because that's the Eaton's way.

Grab your favorite take and bake today and see for yourself.

Order Online

Sheboygan, Take & Bake Pizza FAQs

What temperature and how long do I bake my Eaton's pizza?

Preheat your oven to 375°F and place your pizza on the center rack. Bake for approximately 20–30 minutes until the cheese is melted, bubbly, and the crust turns a beautiful golden brown. Every oven is a little different, so check in toward the end to get it just right.

Can I build my own pizza at the Sheboygan location?

Absolutely! With our Build Your Own pizza option, you choose the size, crust, sauce, cheese, and toppings all your way. You can even split toppings left and right if your group can’t agree on just one!

How long does a Take & Bake pizza stay fresh?

When kept sealed in its original packaging and stored in the refrigerator, your pizza stays fresh for up to 48 hours. We always recommend baking it as soon as you can for the best flavor and texture.

Do you offer gluten-free options at the Sheboygan location?

Yes! We offer gluten-free crust options for those with dietary needs. Our Sheboygan team takes care to prepare gluten-free orders separately. Just let us know when you place your order and we’ll take it from there.

Do you have a kids' pizza option?

We do! Kids can enjoy their own pizza with toppings customized just for them. It’s a great way to get little ones excited about pizza night.